I don’t like to read reviews while a show is running. While I respect the role of the critic in the theatrical ecosystem, I think that there is a delicate alchemy created in the rehearsal room that needs to be protected during a run. As an actor, I find it difficult not to get in my head about what outside people say, and as a writer, I receive enough notes without adding a stranger into the mix. So I shut out the noise and focus on the play that the team created together.
But after the run is over, curiosity gets the better of me, and I read them all! I’m happy to report that the critical response to “ESSPY” at NJ Rep was quite good. BroadwayWorld declared that the play was a “Must-See Incisive Comic-Drama.” Sherri Rase of Q On Stage writes that I have “captured the perfect trio - perfectly realized in our fourth wall bubble that accurately depicts our imperfect world.” And Allen Neuner of Out in NJ offers that the play has “plenty of comic moments, yet like the best comedies, it has moments of serious emotional content as well.” Mr. Neuner also appreciated that it was not a love story which was for me very purposeful. Jay Lustig of NJArts.net also had kind words about the scope and impact of the play.
I’m grateful for the positive reviews and more grateful still for the audiences that came to watch the show. The majority of the shows sold out, and audiences responded warmly every night. I hope this play will have a life beyond the World Premiere!